Generators and uninterruptible power supplies (UPS) are designed to provide back-up power when the mains power supply fails or fluctuates wildly. There is a principle difference between how these two power protection devices achieve this and it lies in the generation and storage of the energy they provide.
Prime Power or Standby Power Generators
Generators can be used as the primary source of power or as a standby power source. As a prime power source, a generating set is in continuous operation. There may be a mains power supply present or the mains may be used as a back-up power source. The site has chosen to run their facilities and systems on generator power continuously and the generating set must be sized for continuous operation.
In a standby power mode, the generating set is used as a standby or secondary source of power. The generator auto-starts when the mains power supply fails or fluctuates outside pre-set parameters. During the start-up period for the generating set, any connected loads can experience a break in power supply. This can be avoided using an uninterruptible power supply.
Uninterruptible Power Supplies
An uninterruptible power supply is designed to provide a stable and secure source of power when the mains power supply fails or fluctuates. This is achieved using a battery set which is charged when mains power is present and an inverter. In an on-line UPS system, the inverter is constantly running. The inverter will be supplied a DC power source from the AC-DC rectifier and battery charging stage or from the battery set.
UPS Systems and Generators
When the mains power supply fails, the UPS system draws power from its connected battery set and an automatic-mains-failure (AMF) panel instructs the generator to start. The UPS uses its connected battery set to maintain power to its inverter as the generator starts and ramps-up to full power. This can take several cycles (milliseconds).
When the UPS system sees a stable electrical power supply from the generator set, the UPS will draw on this source of AC power (as a replacement to the mains power supply) and its battery set will go into recharge.
Long Duration UPS Battery Runtimes
It is common for a UPS system to be installed with a battery pack up to 10-30 minutes when used with a standby power generating set. The generator will typically have a day tank (8-hours) or larger 24-hour fuel tank which can be topped up.
The battery runtime should be enough time for the automatic start-up of the generating set with a contingency for a quick investigation in cases where the generator fails to start. Typical examples include an open-breaker, flat starter battery, air bubbles in the fuel line, contaminated or too low a level of fuel (diesel or liquid petroleum gas – LPG). Many of these instances can be avoided if the generating set is subject to annual or 6-monthly preventative maintenance visits including load bank testing and black-starts. For long duration runtimes, the fuel tank itself can be topped-up using local or emergency fuel deliveries.
In some instances it is not possible to install a standby power generator. Examples include rooftops not designed for such an installation or local environmental concerns re noise pollution. In this instance the UPS system may need a larger battery and charger set. Runtimes up to several hours are possible with a correctly sized and regularly inspected battery set.
Lead Acid UPS Battery Sets
The most commonly installed battery in a UPS system is a valve-regulated lead acid (VRLA). This type of battery is suitable for standby installations where the UPS battery is occasionally called upon to provide a source of standby power.
Lead acid batteries are typically of the 5-year or 10-year design life type, requiring replacement within years 3-4 and 7-8 respectively. Regular annual battery testing of the individual battery blocks can help to identify failing batteries and/or help to extend the time between replacement cycles.
Lithium-ion UPS Batteries and Energy Storage Systems
Lithium-ion batteries are becoming more predominant in every day life. Lithium batteries power our mobiles and tablets and a range of other devices and are the principle replacement or supplementary energy source for petrol and diesel within hybrid or fully electric vehicles. Lithium batteries are also now becoming more popular for use within some UPS installations, whether they have a standby power generator or not.
There are several chemical and manufactured forms of lithium battery available, but they all exhibit similar characteristics and benefits over lead acid type batteries. The principle feature is their ability to rapidly cycle between charge and discharge states, their greater power density and tolerance of higher ambient temperatures. Whilst they do have a higher initial cost the benefits and longer life span (typically from 10-15 years) can lead to a higher return on investment (ROI) for UPS and other energy storage type applications.
Where lithium and lead acid batteries differ is in their electrical charging and power cycling management systems. Lead acid batteries require low-tech charging systems. The batteries cannot be charged too quickly (typically up to 80% within 24hours), requiring a form of trickle charging to maintain their charge state above this and one that is temperature compensating. The materials themselves are typically not flammable and the plastic battery case can be made from fire resistant material.
Lithium batteries are made from a substance that is flammable and a more substantial and sophisticated battery management system is required to protect the batteries during the charge and discharge process and avoid potential for thermal runaway.
|Characteristic||Lead Acid Batteries||Lithium-Ion Batteries|
|Recharge Time||80% within 24 hours||100% within 4 hours|
|Design Life||5 or 10 years||10-15 years|
|Warranty||1-3 years||5-10 years|
|Temperature Range||20-25˚C||Up to 40˚C|
Whilst lead acid batteries remain the leading energy source for UPS system installations, the prices and wider acceptance of lithium batteries as an alternative is gaining momentum within server room and data centre applications. Whichever is the chosen energy storage source there may also be the need for additional standby power in the form of a generating set which provides the additional option of being able to be fuelled and size for continuous running and independence from the power grid.